Are Manchester City ready to win the Premier League?

Roberto Mancini

It has been just over two years since Sheikh Mansour bought Manchester City. Over 500million pounds and a ‘supposed’ World Class manager later, it comes as no surprise that last night’s Manchester derby was billed by Alex Ferguson as the most anticipated Manchester derby in recent times. It was supposed to be the chance for City to show the world that they were no longer the pretenders living in United’s shadow, that the power had shifted and that they were now ready to make a stance and go on and win the Premier League. Well that was yesterday and after a bore draw at Eastlands I was left thinking are City actually good enough to win the league?

If you were expecting end to end football played at a fast pace with the odd bit of handbags, Eastlands was not the place to be last night. Despite Tevez and Rafael trying their best to add a bit of spice to the event, ironically it was the Haye v Harrison advertising boards that were more interesting.

What surprised me about the game was Mancini’s choice of selection. At a time when United seem to be stuttering I really thought City, playing at home would take the game to them. This was their chance to show everyone that they can play good attacking football and really give United a pasting. So I leave myself asking, why did Mancini play 3 defensive midfielders in the middle? Judging by his post match interview it was because Mancini was happy to play for a draw. Despite the millions injected in to the club, it looks like Mancini doesn’t believe his team is good enough to win the title.

Other people may disagree, but I think when it comes to the transfer market Mancini has done as well as he can. To develop a side that can win the title you have to look at previous sides that have done so. Manchester United and Chelsea have dominated the Premier League in recent years and it is definitely these two teams that City must learn from. Despite the flair from abroad, both United and Chelsea have kept a ‘British core’. Whilst Terry and Lampard, are the spine of the Chelsea team Ferdinand, Scholes, Carrick and Rooney do the same for United. What both teams have done is, place flair players such as Ronaldo, Drogba, Malouda around the British players. Man City have tried to replicate this with their transfer policy. Whilst developing Hart in to a world class keeper, they have bought Lescott, Barry and Milner to act as a spine to the team in which they can add creativity to, from abroad.

Man City has also tried to place flair players around the ‘British core’. Tevez, Silva, Ballotelli, Bellamy and Adebayor have all been bought to add the spark to the team. However Man City’s status in world football has left them suffering where United and Chelsea have been able to prosper. Without the coveted Champions League football, Man City haven’t been able to bring the very top players they want. Despite knocking on the door of Kaka, Ronaldinho etc. they have all gone on to play for the European greats. This hasn’t stopped City recruiting talented players, but the aforementioned players all have one thing in common, they bring baggage with them, this is why they want to leave Arsenal, Man Utd, Inter Milan etc. Is it really a surprise when rumours come out of the City training ground that there has been a bust-up? Robinho, Bellamy, Adebayor, Toure, Tevez and Balotelli all have a reputation for being troublemakers with Jose Mourinho even calling Balotelli ‘the son of a wh**e’. Putting all these loose cannons in the same team is definitely going to hinder the dynamics of the group and ultimately be detrimental to the teams performance.

Balotelli Red Card v West Brom - Sourced from

What City really need is to find the balance between discipline and flair just as Man Utd and Chelsea have done in recent years. This is why I feel Mancini opted to play three defensive midfielders against United because the so called flair players are to undisciplined to perform against the top opposition. To find that balance City have to be in the Champions League, without Champions League football they will only attract the best players who are unsettled at top European clubs or up and coming players from clubs without European status (i.e. Milner and Barry moving from Aston Villa).

As far as I’m concerned, without Champions league football, City will not win the league. Despite having a British core which I believe is essential to winning the Premier League, they lack talented players who also are willing to play as part of the team. They need the Champions league so that they can bring in the ‘next level’ of footballer to develop the side. By the ‘next level’ I mean top class players such as Ozil, Ronaldo, Messi and Iniesta. Players who are extremely talented but also have a level head. I think Mancini knows this and I think he will most definitely be setting his sights on the top four this season.

If City do make the top four, This time next year the answer to my question ‘Are Manchester City ready to win the Premier League?’ would be very different…or at least I would expect it to be.

If you have enjoyed this article please subscribe or follow us on Twitter / Facebook using the links in the top right hand corner of the page!


About patrickfc
I am 22 years old and co-founder of upper90magazine. I love all things football...Whether its a cold and rainy Saturday watching Rushden & Diamonds or an evening International match at Wembley Stadium.

6 Responses to Are Manchester City ready to win the Premier League?

  1. Tom McSharry says:

    I agree; I don’t think they are ready to win it this season. United were missing Giggs, Valencia and Rooney, three world class, regular starting 11 players and yet still dominated a game away from home, against a strong City line up who should definitely have been looking for a win, given the United injury list and as you say, the current form of United.

    CIty getting champions league football next season would certainly improve their chances of pulling in bigger names, but I don’t think they need that…they need time to settle and buying in bigger names will just unsettle the big names they already have. It just goes to show, you can’t buy a winning team…you have to develop one.

    • patrickfc says:

      Some good points there Tom. I think you are right, you can’t just purely buy a winning team, you need the foundations at the club in the first place. However I think you can buy big players to place around the foundations. Look at Chelsea for example; they had Lampard and Terry and then they bought the likes of Drogba, Essien, Malouda etc.

      The difference between Chelsea and Man City is 1) when Abrahmovic put money into Chelsea they already were in the Champions League, so could still attract big players, 2) They had an English ‘core’ (Terry + Lampard) at the club already whereas City have had to buy players to become the English ‘core’ which will obviously take more time!

  2. Pingback: The Premier League Title Race; Does anyone actually want to win it this year? « upper90magazine

  3. Matt Liamson says:

    Great article, hit the nail on the head here!

  4. Austin says:

    The players that will ultimately make the difference between champions and contenders are the players that pull the shirt on with an immense amount of pride & passion and a will to win for the crest they bare on there chest. Usually players that have come through the youth system and have a genuine sense of repaying the faith that has been shown in them from an early age, the likes of Terry at Chelsea, and the famous class of ’99 at United which won the treble. These players aren’t necessarily British.

    These players are not limited to those who have come through the youth system. Rooney at United clearly displays the same passion, to his detriment at times, as the Scholes and Nevilles of this world. Frank Lampard, despite a massive affiliation with West Ham for a large part of his career is clearly a Chelsea man now and plays with a desire to win football matches for that club and the fans. All of the above will go down both in there respected clubs history as ‘greats’. There names will be mentioned in years to come during fan polls about ‘greatest ever players to play for…’, littered with honors as all there careers have been so far, they will also be remembered for that passion they showed. John Terry putting his body on the line week in week out, Rooney’s tackling back, Paul Scholes undeniable dedication to his sport and club. Didier Drogbas outbursts and actions, undefendable at times, however, show a great desire to win for his team mates as well as himself.

    The current Manchester City team does not contain any such players. Players with a degree of genius, yes, players with pride, passion and a dedication for the crest on those sky blue shirts, no.

    At Manchester City they have clearly missed a trick. They did have such a spine. Dunn, Onuoha, Ireland and Johnson. Three of which are no longer at the club, and one despite his injury troubles, will certainly not be a fixture in the Manchester City line up when fully fit.

    Milner, Barry and Lescott, all excellent players in there own right, all competing for a starting berth in the England side, are typical of the modern footballer. They play for themselves. All three were undoubtedly attracted by the money and potential for success that Manchester City could offer, but, I don’t believe any could honestly say had always dreamed of playing for Manchester City as a youngster, or have that connection which the above mentioned have with there clubs.

    These players are the difference. I may be proved wrong come the end of the season, Manchester City may well lift the Premier League trophy, one of the hardest titles in World football to win (IMO – more so than the Champions League).

  5. Pingback: game tester mythreason

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: